Tuesday 15 March 2022

So sorry, Johor

So, it has come to this,


That, despite this,

38 Johor BN reps submit SDs to palace supporting Hasni 

I have checked the story and it's true.

Johor BN indeed tried but was unsuccessful to stop the whole thing from happening.

It's too weak to defend the people's democratic rights. Even with that two-thirds majority.

Well, I will keep my words; I will not vote for BN in GE15 and I will pray for the new Johor MB's uncle Hishammuddin Hussein to lose in Semberong in that coming election.

That's the least that I could do.

As for this blog, I will once again turn it into a neutral platform.

For Johoreans, these are excerpts of an article published in Berita Harian in 2019,

Sultan Azlan Shah menerusi tulisannya The Role of Constitutional Rulers in Malaysia menyatakan:

“biarpun benar bahawa pelantikan seseorang Menteri Besar adalah prerogatif Sultan, baginda tidak bebas untuk melantik sesiapa yang disukai. Apabila parti yang memenangi majoriti kerusi memutuskan untuk mencalonkan seorang daripada ahlinya, Sultan terbabit tidak mempunyai pilihan kecuali melantiknya.”

Ini jelas menunjukkan kegagalan mematuhi konvensyen ini akan menyebabkan Sultan terbabit dalam politik partisan. Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) mungkin boleh meluluskan undi tidak percaya terhadap Menteri Besar yang baru dilantik. Jika perkara itu berlaku, pasti boleh memalukan baginda dan seterusnya membawa kepada krisis Perlembagaan.

Pertimbangan ikut budi bicara

Bagaimanapun, sesetengah situasi mengizinkan baginda membuat pertimbangan mengikut budi bicara tersendiri. Antaranya jika kedudukan DUN ‘tergantung’ dan tiada mana-mana pihak memiliki majoriti, selain pihak majoriti berbelah bahagi dalam soal pemilihan ketua. Hal sama berlaku jika terdapat gabungan dan ia berbelah bahagi dalam pemilihan ketua.

Ketika berlaku pembubaran juga, Menteri Besar meninggal dunia atau meletak jawatan, maka Sultan mempunyai kuasa untuk memilih Menteri Besar sementara.

Artikel 4(2) dan 7(2) (a) mengenai pelantikan Menteri Besar oleh Sultan, mestilah dibaca dengan mengambil kira kandungan Perlembagaan yang mengandungi ciri-ciri demokrasi berikut (a) Menteri Besar bukan wizir/wazir peribadi kepada Sultan, tetapi dipilih DUN; (b) Menteri Besar dan EXCO perlu menjawab kepada DUN, bukan kepada Sultan: Artikel 4(5); (c) terdapat DUN yang dipilih: Artikel 15; (d) Menteri Besar boleh dipecat oleh DUN melalui undi tidak percaya: Artikel 4(6); dan (e) Sultan adalah Raja Berperlembagaan yang mesti bertindak atas nasihat yang dikawal situasi tertentu apabila budi bicara diperlukan.

Tiada kuasa bubarkan DUN

Timbul juga persoalan adakah Sultan memiliki kuasa untuk membubarkan DUN? Jawapannya tidak.

Perkara 23 menyebut baginda mempunyai kuasa untuk memulakan dan menangguhkan DUN, tetapi atas nasihat. Begitu juga dengan Perkara 23(2) yang menyebut baginda mempunyai kuasa untuk membubarkan pada peringkat pertengahan, walaupun DUN belum berakhir, tetapi juga atas nasihat dan ini tertakluk kepada Perkara 7(1).

26 comments:

  1. i am too scared to comment anything.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tindakan Yang Bijak olih saudara HY.Saya pun tak mahu Komen apa,perkara ini melibatkan golongan yang tidak bolih Di sentuh.cuma nak Komen,KESIAN BN JOHOR.

      Delete
  2. hopefully someone puts up a no confidence vote on day 1 of sitting & both sides of the aisle stick up for the people.



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Does umno hv the guts to do so, i dont think so, since khaled nordin mb wasnt the one who call the shots

      Delete
  3. Kupasan yg begitu rational;

    https://youtu.be/ggPBxkJP4nw

    Professor Nasi Lemak

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. one good blessing of this outcome is
      some ingrates SJK Chino "brain washed" my son and his grp
      wll be stuck in Soth island as "Ambasoddors de Trolleys"
      kutip kutip selepas makan kaum kafirs

      Delete
  4. Hari yang sedih buat MALAYSIA 🇲🇾, sama ada Kalian adalah totok BN, pendokong PN, pendamba PH, golongan merosakkan undi, para pemerhati dan every and each democrat.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A successful power play to seize control of whole Johor wealth for the next 5 years. May this whomever Onn bring forth abandunt "ong" prosperity to all Johoreans.

    ReplyDelete
  6. To quote WS:
    Some are born great. Some achieve greatness. Some have greatness thrust upon them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Takabur nya, ...there is another category, istidraj

      Delete
    2. annine
      what gonna happen if the "council of rulers" rejected the "expired dinosaurs" of jibby, wak jawa, is-telor penyu
      and instead agrredable to khari, H2O, Aismi as PieM

      Delete
    3. Some are born great.. silver spooner
      Some achieve greatness.. high achiever.
      Some who greatness thrust upon then... silver platterer.
      There will always exist these kind of peoples.

      Delete
  7. Hang Jebat...raja adil raja disembah, raja zalim raja di sanggah...
    Zahid Hamidi, adakah anda Hang Jebat???
    Atau tempat Zahid hamidi di penjara???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Zahid can't afford to do so lah.. he may need a royal pardon sometime in the future

      Delete
  8. KIMAK......

    "The frontrunner for the post of Johor Menteri Besar Onn Hafiz Ghazi has already run into controversy as the public is reminded about his involvement in the 1MDB’s (1Malaysia Development Bhd) false narrative.

    Onn Hafiz, the nephew of Defence Minister Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein, was the operator of the now defunct portal Malaysian Digest.

    The portal had received payment from then prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak as part of the latter’s media and public relations blitz in support of his administration as well as the doomed 1MDB venture which eventually cost Malaysian taxpayers upwards of RM20 billion.

    On April 23, 2019, Onn Hafiz told the Kuala Lumpur High Court that his company Vital Spire Sdn Bhd received a cheque for RM240,000 from Najib to launch the Malaysian Digest portal."

    What has poor Johor done to deserve this fate?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You reap what you sow. You put jester you get clowned. Never pity them they deserved every ounce of it.

      Delete
  9. Onn Hafiz Ghazi may turn out to be a blessing in disguise for bangsa johor. I love bangsa johor and I think the sultan have made the right choice. Hidup Bangsa Johor

    ReplyDelete
  10. hopefully all the YBs put up a no confidence vote on day 1 of sitting & both sides of the aisle stick up for the people.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Onn Hafiz Ghazi is a good guy. He is young vibrant and resourceful. Bangsa Johor should be thankful to have him as the new MB.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Are u saying that the rest of the Umno Adun, none are young, vibrant, resourceful & competent?

      Admit it la, he got the job because he is the grandson of a pm, therefor experience doesn't matter, just like najib, already an mb in his 30s. Enough said..

      Delete
    2. But I agree... beter him that Puad zakarshi

      Delete
  12. $64,000 question is, was it an umno internal power play or was it the palace ?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Apo ni ... semuo takdo tolo nak komen .

    TMJ dah muak main bola ...
    Dio nak main politik lakkk ...

    Di doakan berjayolah .. saperti JDT .

    InSyaAllah .

    Waghih

    ReplyDelete
  14. Assuming , MB On Hafiz ni gagal dlm melaksanokan tugasan ...
    Siapo kono jawab ...?

    Waghih.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Define gagal. Kalau payung kuning, umno lords & putra happy, semua ok. Rakyat biasa kena sedar diri,angan2 kena lebih rendah dari rumput

      Delete
  15. If sedition act is abolished, I will write my piece in here on what I think of the Johore royals

    ReplyDelete